However, Meghan and Harry chose to decline this title to prevent potential bullying due to the word "dumb" in it, which carries negative connotations in the United States, where they currently reside.
According to sources, both Meghan and Harry were concerned about the possible implications of Archie being associated with the word "dumb." Instead, Archie is known as Master Archie Harrison Mountbatten-Windsor. This decision sparked controversy in Scotland, where Dumbarton is located, as locals are accustomed to the place name being associated with the title.
David Byrne, who hails from Dumbarton and is a highly accomplished musician known for his work with the New Wave band Talking Heads, expressed disappointment in Meghan and Harry's choice of words. He remarked that their comments were thoughtless and left the people of Dumbarton feeling awkward. Byrne urged the government to revoke the family's title as a response to their actions.
Social media users, both from Dumbarton and beyond, defended the town against the criticism. Many emphasized that the Dumbarton community does not care about the London Gentry and cannot relate to them. Others expressed pride in their connection to Dumbarton, highlighting the town's historical significance as the ancient capital of the Kingdom of Strathclyde and its notable landmark, Dumbarton Castle.
Dumbarton has a rich history, and its contributions to Scottish trade in shipbuilding, glassmaking, and whiskey-making have been significant. The town's heritage and sense of identity are cherished by its residents, making them resilient to external judgments.
The controversy over the rejected title has sparked a conversation about language, sensitivity, and cultural understanding. While the situation has caused tension, it has also brought attention to the town of Dumbarton and its illustrious past.
