Many readers found it tedious, repetitive, and poorly written, resulting in low ratings on platforms like Goodreads and Amazon. Expert analysis revealed that Harry's book secured the fourth lowest rating among celebrity authors over the past three years, averaging 1.5 out of five. In contrast, legends like Sir Paul McCartney achieved high ratings, with "The Lyrics" receiving an impressive 4.75 out of five.
The poor reception directly impacted sales, falling significantly below expectations. "Spare" managed to sell only 200,000 copies worldwide, while "The Lyrics" surpassed 2 million copies sold. Harry's book failed to secure a spot in the top 10 bestseller lists in the UK and the US, whereas "The Lyrics" topped charts in both countries. Penguin Random House, which reportedly paid Harry an advance of at least $20 million for the memoir, now faces substantial losses, turning the venture into a costly mistake.
Sources indicate that the publisher is demanding the return of the advance or a substantial portion, citing Harry's failure to meet promises and obligations. The publisher is discontent with Harry's lack of cooperation and promotion, as he declined interviews and events to support the book's launch. In response, Harry, reluctant to reimburse the money, blames the publisher for the book's failure and accuses them of leaking it to the press before the release date, damaging its reputation and sales.
The memoir's fallout has strained Harry's relationship with Meghan, who is reportedly furious over him exposing their private lives. Concerns arise for Meghan's own book deal with Penguin Random House, fearing its prospects and credibility may be affected. Furthermore, Harry's memoir has exacerbated tensions with his family and country, alienating and offending many. Calls from royal fans and commentators demanding Harry's removal of royal titles and privileges, coupled with an apology to his family and the nation, have intensified.
The overall conclusion is that Harry's memoir has proven disastrous for everyone involved, showcasing a significant misstep in leaving his royal role for a Hollywood fantasy. He has lost respect and support from family, country, and publisher, gaining only ridicule and resentment. The prince is viewed as a spoiled and selfish individual, lacking a sense of duty or loyalty, who has scripted his own downfall with no one else to blame but himself.
